Casting With Confidence: Key Considerations For Selecting A Baitcasting Reel

Last updated:

Disclosure: Some posts contain affiliate links, which earn us a commission if you make a purchase through them. Positive Fishing © participates in various affiliate networks including the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program.

Baitcasting reels provide the ultimate casting performance, and once you have mastered how to use them, your casting distances and accuracy will go through the roof. 

Choosing the best baitcasting reel is a pivotal decision, far more than your rod choice! My 20 years of fishing experience have taught me that using the right baitcasting reel will improve your fishing skills, giving you greater control and precision with every cast.

Understanding the mechanics of the reel is crucial before making a purchase. The spool tension, braking systems, and the reel’s gear ratio all affect its performance. For those new to baitcasting, grasping these basics will make it easier to master casting and, ultimately, the enjoyment and success you’ll have fishing. Matching the reel to your style of fishing, whether flipping jigs for bass or casting for inshore species, lends itself to a far less frustrating day of fishing!

However, selecting a baitcasting reel isn’t just about the specifications. It also involves considering your budget and the type of fishing you’ll be doing most often. With my knowledge, I’ve learned that investing in a reel with the right features for your needs is just as important as practicing your casting technique.

Key Takeaways

  • A baitcasting reel offers precision and control for experienced anglers.
  • Matching the reel to fishing style is crucial for a seamless experience.
  • Consideration of budget and essential features is key to a wise purchase.

Comparing A Baitcaster Reel With A Spinning Reel

I opt for a baitcasting reel when aiming for precision and plan to use heavier lines and lures. This type of reel sits atop the rod, making it easier for me to monitor and control my cast. With a baitcasting reel, I experience fewer line twists thanks to the line coming off the spool directly in line with the rod, and while it takes practice to master, it provides far more accuracy once I do.

In contrast, spinning reels hang below the rod and are much easier to use, which makes them a great choice for beginners. They have an open spool and bail arm, which can be flipped to release the line. When I use a spinning reel, I don’t worry about the backlash or “bird’s nests” that can happen with baitcasters, especially when dealing with light lures and lines. However, spinning reels don’t match the same level of control and efficiency I get with heavier lines that baitcasters provide.

Here’s a quick breakdown of the main features of each reel:

FeatureBaitcasterSpinning Reel
Position on RodTopBottom
Line TwistMinimalMore Common
Ease of UseRequires PracticeUser-Friendly
Line ControlHighModerate
Lure WeightBetter with heavy luresBetter with light lures
Casting AccuracyExcellentGood

I enjoy using both reels for different scenarios. My choice between a baitcaster and a spinning reel comes down to what I’m targeting, where I’m fishing, and my personal level of experience.

How To Cast A Baitcasting Reel?

Baitcasting reels are not easy to use and are considerably more difficult than spinning reels, as you must control the line leaving the spool with your thumb. Getting it wrong leads to many backlashes, bird’s nests, and tangles you might spend hours undoing. 

When I approach casting my baitcasting reel, the first thing I do is adjust the spool tension. I tighten the knob just until the lure starts to drop slowly when I release the reel.

Next, I set the brake system. Whether it’s a magnetic brake or a centrifugal brake, I ensure it’s tuned to match the weight of my lure and current casting conditions.

To begin the casting motion, I grip the rod behind the reel, keeping my thumb on the spool to control the release of the line. Here’s a quick checklist I follow:

  • Reel in the line so my lure or bait is about 12 inches from the rod tip.
  • Push the button to release the spool, keeping my thumb lightly on it.
  • Raise the rod to a 10 to 2 o’clock position; this is my casting range.
  • I swing the rod forward, releasing my thumb from the spool as my rod reaches the 2 o’clock position.
  • Press my thumb down again to stop the spool as soon as the lure hits the target.

Practicing casting in an open area (such as a park) is important to fine-tune these steps. I also recommend practicing with heavier lures before moving on to lighter ones. It’s all about finding a balance between control and power, which comes with experience and patience.

Understanding Baitcasting Reel Basics

In choosing the perfect baitcasting reel, it’s essential to understand its components, the varied types, and the critical role of gear ratios.

Parts Of A Baitcasting Reel

The anatomy of a baitcasting reel is more complex than a spinning reel’s. Major components include the handle, drag system, spool, braking system, and caster control knob. My casting reel has the spool aligned perpendicularly to the rod, which allows for greater casting accuracy and control of the line.

Reel Types: Round vs Low Profile

Round baitcasters are typically larger and can hold more line, making them ideal for catching larger fish or for situations requiring longer casts. On the other hand, low-profile reels fit more snugly in my palm and are generally more comfortable to use for extended periods, which is especially handy when pursuing smaller species or casting frequently.

The Importance Of Gear Ratios

A gear ratio in a baitcasting reel determines how many times the spool turns for each turn of the handle. High ratios like 7.1:1 mean the spool rotates 7.1 times for every handle turn, translating to fast retrieves ideal for quick-moving baits. Conversely, lower gear ratios like 5.4:1 offer more torque, helping me pull in heavier fish.

Understanding and matching the gear ratio to my preferred fishing techniques and the chosen bait types is an important factor in deciding what gear ratio I need.

Selecting The Right Reel For Your Fishing Style

When I select a baitcasting reel, I focus on the specific lures and techniques I plan to use, considering the balance of speed and control and ensuring the reel operates smoothly with quality ball bearings.

Matching Reels To Lures And Techniques

Baitcasting reels are uniquely suited for precision fishing techniques like flipping and pitching, especially when targeting species like bass. For instance, heavy lures such as swimbaits and crankbaits demand a reel with a substantial drag system and a frame that can withstand the stress. In contrast, lighter lures like spinnerbaits are best paired with a reel that offers finesse and accuracy in casting.

Speed vs Control: Balancing Retrieve Rate

My choice of reel also involves deciding between retrieve rate and control. A higher gear ratio, such as 7.5:1, means faster retrieval, which is ideal for techniques where quick lure action is key, like with certain spinnerbaits when bass fishing, where quick reflexes are necessary. Conversely, a lower gear ratio, around 5.4:1, offers more torque for crankbaits and can improve my control when fighting larger fish.

The Role of Ball Bearings and Smooth Operation

Finally, the number of ball bearings indicates a reel’s smoothness and stability, which are imperative for consistent performance. A higher count of quality ball bearings ensures that the reel functions smoothly, which is crucial when precision and a steady retrieve are needed for bait presentations. Baitcasting reels with more bearings typically offer more refined and controlled casting and retrieval, contributing to a successful day of fishing.

Advanced Features And Customization

In my experience, advanced features and customization can significantly enhance the performance of a baitcasting reel. Essential aspects such as the braking system, material construction, and the ability to fine-tune settings all contribute to precision casting and comfort.

Braking Systems: Centrifugal vs Magnetic

The first element to consider is the braking system, which is crucial in preventing backlash—when the spool spins faster than the line is cast out, resulting in a tangle. Here’s a quick comparison:

  • Centrifugal Brakes: Use friction-based, mechanical resistance. They typically involve pins that extend outward due to centrifugal force to slow down the spool.
  • Magnetic Brakes: Rely on a magnetic field to control the spool speed. The magnetic resistance increases as my thumb nears the spool to slow the cast.

For precision casting in varying conditions, I tend to prefer centrifugal brakes for their adjustability, though magnetic systems can be more user-friendly, especially for those new to baitcasters.

Fine-Tuning A Baitcasting Reel For Precision Casting

Mastering fine-tuning is key for precise casts. This often involves adjusting the tension knob to match the lure weight and the spool tension for controlled descent. Here’s how I adjust for precision:

  1. Start with the Tension Knob: I set it so the lure falls slowly when released and then increase the tension slightly.
  2. Balance with the Braking System: Next, I adjust the brake setting based on casting conditions and my preferred resistance.

For maximum control, I also recommend reels with dual braking systems that combine both centrifugal and magnetic brakes, as this allows more nuanced adjustment based on my casting style and conditions.

Material Choices: Aluminum vs Graphite Frames

The material makeup of a baitcaster is fundamental to its performance and durability. Here are the primary options:

  • Aluminum Frames: Generally more rigid and robust, excellent for saltwater applications due to their corrosion-resistant properties. Forged aluminum is particularly durable, though it often produces a heavier reel.
  • Graphite Frames: They tend to be lighter, which reduces arm fatigue during long fishing sessions. However, they may flex more under heavy loads, impacting precision.

For anglers considering line type, aluminum frames often pair well with braided lines, as they can handle the added stress without deforming. Sealed bearings made from stainless steel or ceramic are also a plus in aluminum and graphite frames, as they provide longevity and smooth operation during casting and retrieval. If comfort is a priority, always check for a grip that fits in your hand well and provides sufficient leverage without slipping.

Making The Purchase: Budgeting And Recommendations

When ready to purchase a baitcasting reel, it’s crucial to weigh the investment against the value it provides and recognize the reputable brands for a well-informed decision.

Deciding On A Price Range: Investment vs Value

I find it essential to establish a budget that aligns with my fishing goals.

A reliable entry-level reel between $40 to $100 can be found for newcomers, offering a balance between cost and functionality.

More experienced anglers should aim for a price range of $100 to $200, as reels in this bracket typically feature advanced technologies like magnetic or centrifugal braking systems for better casting control.

For me, high-end reels offer precision and unparalleled smoothness in the $200 to $500 range, justified for targeting heavy cover or open water with baits like a buzzbait.

So, What Are The Top Baitcasting Reels

Fishing reels from Abu GarciaShimano, and Daiwa are consistently top picks. The Abu Garcia Revo X LP, with its robust max drag and smooth performance, stands out within its price bracket for both beginners and experts. The Shimano Curado line is acclaimed for its durability and ease of use, ideal for those practicing their casting with various bait types. For anglers seeking lighter reels with the prowess to handle bigger fish, the Daiwa Tatula 300 is exemplary, especially when paired with the right fishing rod. It’s important to note the gear ratios; for me, a high gear ratio is best for baits like buzzbait, where rapid retrieval is necessary, while a moderate ratio suits versatile fishing techniques.

In conclusion, I can make informed decisions on the optimal baitcasting reel that caters to my specific angling needs and financial constraints by understanding these elements.

  • Lew’s Tournament MP Baitcasting Reel – My Best Overall Pick!
  • Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C3 Baitcast Reel – My Most Versatile Pick!
  • KastKing Royale Legend GT Baitcasting Reel – My Best Budget Pick!
  • Shimano Curado K Baitcaster Reel – My Best Quality Pick!
  • Abu Garcia Revo Toro Beast X Low Profile Baitcasting Reel – My Best Saltwater Pick!
  • KastKing Spartacus II Baitcasting Fishing Reel – My Best Beginners Pick!
  • Daiwa Tatula 200 TWS Baitcasting Reel – Best Lure Use Pick!
Best saltwater baitcasting reel
Baitcasting reels are for saltwater and freshwater – note how the reel is positioned on top of the rod, not underneath like a spinning reel

Whenever possible, try to match your bait caster reel and rod, and also make sure you buy the right or left-handed version you need. Most reels for baitcasting are not interchangeable, and only very few are ambidextrous, like the Daiwa Tatula 200.    

Lew’s Tournament MP Baitcasting Reel – My Best Overall Pick!

​​The Lew’s Tournament MP Baitcasting Reel is designed for professional baitcasters who have mastered throwing these super fast reels without creating any backlashes. 

What makes this reel so great is how reliable it is. Built with an aluminum frame and high-quality components, you can rest assured that this reel will last, handle a few knocks, and provide excellent performance for a long time. 

The reel features nine ball bearings that transfer load excellently so you can crank smoothly, even when under pressure. The gear ratio and, thus, retrieve rate is off the charts at 31 inches per second, so you can gather slack in seconds and put a ton of pressure on fish in the fight. 

The drag system on this reel is excellent, too. With a max of 20 lbs of pressure, you can stop fish easily, and it is smooth, too, with close to zero start-up inertia. The reel is also incredibly light, so you won’t be fighting or casting with any extra weight, making it comfortable to hold for several hours. 

The braking system on this reel can be hard to get used to, but once you do, it will be like a match made in heaven. You may suffer a few backlashes at first, though, until you master it. This reel is priced at the mid-range, but it is well worth it for the quality you get.


  • Lightweight for comfy casting 
  • Works well for inshore and freshwater fishing 
  • Durable build that lasts   
  • Lots of ball bearings for smooth performance 
  • Cranks like butter 
  • Awesome max drag of 20 lbs 
  • Super smooth crank with an excellent gear ratio 
  • Great to cast with when the brakes are dialed in 
  • Incredible retrieve of 31-inches per crank


  • It takes a while to get used to the braking system
  • A little expensive 


  • Mono capacity LB/YD: 12/120
  • Braid capacity LB/YD: 50/120
  • Max Drag: 20 lbs 
  • Gear Ratio: 7.5:1
  • Ball bearings: 9+1
  • Weight: 6.9 oz
  • Retrieve rate per crank: 31 inches
  • Retrieve Side: Left or right

Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C3 Baitcast Reel – My Most Versatile Pick! 

The Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C3 Baitcast Reel is the perfect choice for anyone looking for a baitcaster that can match up to some serious trophy-size saltwater and freshwater fish. This is the reel I have used as a saltwater flats fishing guide across countries such as Seychelles and Mexico, despite being over five years since I purchased one.

This reel is built to be bomb-proof with its machined, corrosion-blocking aluminum frame. The use of quality aluminum makes it a little heavy compared to others, but even if you treat this reel badly, it will only come back for more.

The Ambassadeur C3 features an excellent line capacity, holding 310 yards with a 30lb braid. There isn’t much you can’t catch, from sailfish, permit, and tarpon will be caught with this reel. Once hooked up, the super smooth carbon matrix drag system has some serious stopping power, and the solid retrieve rate gives you everything in the fight. 

When it comes to casting, the C3 makes things easy, as the brake is easy to adjust and provides consistent pressure, so once it is dialed into your casting stroke, you should get it right every time. 

The reel also features anti-reverse, which means you can use it for live baiting, as you can drop your bait back and let the fish take it before setting the hook. 


  • Incredibly durable 
  • The solid aluminum frame can handle rough treatment 
  • Massive line capacity 
  • Great max drag
  • The carbon drag system is super smooth  
  • Built to survive in saltwater 
  • Easy to adjust and fine-tune the brake 
  • Great and easy to cast with 
  • Comes with anti-reverse for live baiting 
  • Great value 


  • Quite heavy 


  • Mono capacity LB/YD: 12/320
  • Braid capacity LB/YD: 30/310
  • Max Drag: 15 lbs 
  • Gear Ratio: 5.3:1
  • Ball bearings: 4
  • Weight: 10.70 oz 
  • Retrieve rate per crank: 26 inches 
  • Retrieve Side: Left or right

KastKing Royale Legend GT Baitcasting Reel – My Best Budget Pick! 

The KastKing Royale Legend GT Baitcasting Reel is another awesome, affordable option that packs a punch at its price point.

The Royal Legend is designed to be used in freshwater and saltwater fishing and is built from brass, stainless steel, and aluminum – all materials that handle corrosion well. The specs also stack up for large species, with a max drag of 17.6 lbs, a solid line capacity, and a super fast retrieve rate. 

The quadruple disc carbon drag is very smooth for the quality, and there is close to no start-up inertia. The crank is smooth thanks to the 5 + 1 double-shielded stainless steel bearing and gearing system that transfers load perfectly. 

The magnetic brake system uses eight magnets to provide the perfect casting tension, but it adjusts very sensitively, so dialing in may take a while. This makes it a great reel for beginners who have limited knowledge. 

The main complaint about this reel is that it is noisy when cast. This doesn’t bother me, but it does bother some anglers. Overall, though, it is a great baitcasting reel for the money. 


  • Great for use in fresh and saltwater 
  • Very affordable for the quality 
  • A good reel for beginners to start with 
  • The drag is reliable and butter-smooth
  • The braking system is simple 
  • Casting is quite easy with this reel 
  • Awesome max drag
  • Super high retrieve rate 


  • It is a little noisy when casting 
  • The brake adjustments are sensitive 


  • Mono capacity LB/YD: 10/130,12/110,14/90
  • Braid capacity  LB/YD: 40/130, 50/110, 65/90
  • Drag: 17.6lb
  • Gear Ratio: 7.0:1
  • Ball bearings: 11+1
  • Weight: 7.51oz
  • Retrieve rate, per crank: 31.5 inch
  • Retrieve Side: Right or Left 

Shimano Curado K Baitcaster Reel – My Best Quality Pick!

Shimano makes some of the best fishing equipment on the planet, from rods to reels, and the Shimano Curado K Baitcaster Reel is no different. 

The Curado K reel is built to last forever and is one of the longest-lasting baitcasting reels on the market. Not only is it made from super durable materials, it is also built to be easily maintained, and with some basic tender loving care, you will have this reel forever and be able to hand it down to your kids. 

One of my favorite things about this reel is the braking system. It is super easy to use and find the perfect tension, making casting easier and reducing backlashes. When you combine this with the super-fast spool, you can achieve some incredible casting distances. 

The Curado also features Shimano’s micro module gearing and x-ship technology, which work together for really smooth performance and efficiency. It makes every crank count, the winding feels almost effortless, and the drag is top quality, too. 

Overall, the Curado K is a very impressive reel with amazing performance and long-lasting durability but a little expensive. The carbon bodied, top-of-the-range, low-profile version costs under $200. However, you should consider it an investment as it will easily last a lifetime. 


  • The quality braking system is easy to use
  • Easy to cast with for a baitcaster 
  • Great for long casting distances 
  • Super fast reel 
  • Great for freshwater and light inshore fishing 
  • Super smooth drag and retrieve 
  • Durable and will last forever with care 
  • Excellent Shimano quality 


  • Quite expensive 


  • Mono capacity LB/YD: 8/180, 10/155, 14/110
  • Braid capacity LB/YD: 30/190, 50/120, 65/80
  • Max Drag: 11 lbs
  • Gear Ratio: 6.2:1   
  • Ball bearings: 6+1
  • Weight: 7.6 oz
  • Retrieve rate per crank: 26 inches 
  • Retrieve Side: Left or right

Abu Garcia Revo Toro Beast X Low Profile Baitcasting Reel – My Best Saltwater Pick!

The Abu Garcia Revo Toro Beast X Low Profile Baitcasting Reel is one of the top reels, period! It performs in every way and even in the harshest of environments! You can use it to catch everything from giant sea specimens to some good-sized specimen bass and huge predators like pike. 

This reel couldn’t be built from better materials and features an X2-cräftic aluminum alloy frame and side plate, stainless steel High Performance Corrosion Resistant bearings, and a carbon matrix drag. These components that make up this reel are tougher than nails and laugh easily in the face of saltwater and corrosion. 

The specs on the Revo are also top of the line with a retrieve rate of 27 inches per crank and a max drag of 30 lbs. You can get over 300 yards of 20-lb braid on there. With this combination, you can literally handle most fish on the planet. 

The Revo’s smoothness is off the charts, too, both when you wind in under pressure and when you are casting. The magnetic braking system is simple to adjust in incremental steps to find the perfect casting tension immediately. 

Once the brake is set, you can cast incredible distances with this reel and accurately, too, so long as you pair it with a fast-action but sensitive rod. 

The only issue with the Abu Garcia Revo Toro Beast is the price, which is just over $300. It is a hugely expensive reel, so it should be when you consider the performance and durability! 


  • Great for fresh and saltwater
  • Huge line capacity and max drag 
  • Perfect for big species 
  • Bomb-proof build using strong materials 
  • The drag is incredibly smooth 
  • Retrieve is excellent under pressure 
  • The braking system is simple and very effective 
  • Cast long distances accurately with ease 


  • Super expensive 
  • The retrieve rate could be higher 


  • Mono capacity LB/YD: 12/240 14/205 17/170
  • Braid capacity LB/YD: 20/310 30/235 50/165
  • Max Drag: 30 lbs
  • Gear Ratio: 5.8:1
  • Ball bearings: 5+1
  • Weight: 9.5 oz 
  • Retrieve rate per crank: 27 inches 
  • Retrieve Side: Left or right

KastKing Spartacus II Baitcasting Fishing Reel – My Best Beginners Pick!

The KastKing Spartacus II Baitcasting Fishing Reel is an awesome option for anyone shopping on a budget and for beginners starting out baitcasting, too. 

This baitcaster reel is built to be used in all environments, from freshwater to saltwater, and it comes with enough gusto to handle many of the species there, too. With up to 17.64 lbs of super smooth drag power and a super fast retrieve rate, you have some serious fish-stopping power once you are hooked up.

With over seven ball bearings, winding this reel is as smooth as can be, even when the spool is under pressure. With a retrieve rate of 28 inches per crank, you can quickly fish lures and gather lines fast on every pump. 

Casting with this reel is excellent once the braking system is adjusted correctly. It has two brakes that need setting so you can dial in the perfect amount of tension. Getting this right can be hard, especially for beginners, but once it is correct, casting becomes very easy. 

Overall, this is an incredible reel for the price, but it might not suit pros as it isn’t as high-performing as other, more expensive baitcaster reels.  At around $50, it’s well worth the money.


  • Works well for fresh and saltwater fishing  
  • Superlight for long casting days 
  • Dual brakes ensure easy casting 
  • Simple to use, great for beginners 
  • Awesome retrieve rate 
  • Solid line capacity 
  • Great max drag 
  • Awesome price for the quality 


  • It is quite hard to get the braking system right  
  • Double brakes will annoy season baitcaster anglers 
  • A bit slow for professionals 


  • Mono capacity LB/YD: 10/140, 12/110, 15/90
  • Braid capacity LB/YD: 20/270, 30/140, 40/115
  • Max Drag: 17.64 lbs 
  • Gear Ratio: 7.2:1
  • Ball bearings: 7+1
  • Weight: 6.0 oz
  • Retrieve rate per crank: 28 inches
  • Retrieve Side: Left or right 

Daiwa Tatula 200 TWS Baitcasting Reel – Best For Lures Pick!

The Daiwa Tatula 200 TWS Baitcasting Reel is one of Diawa’s best baitcaster ever offerings, as it is simple and easy to cast while performing quite amazingly. 

Built from a combination of quality aluminum, brass, and stainless steel while still maintaining a low weight, this reel is as durable as can be. You can use it in saltwater without worrying about corrosion; of course, it will work in freshwater well, too. 

Between the line capacity and the max drag, this reel can handle some big fish but also performs well for small fish. The brake system is super simple to use, making casting easier, and the spool is super fast so that you can cast heavy and light lures at awesome distances. 

The carbon drag system is incredibly smooth, the ball bearings ensure the crank is fine, and the reel is designed to be as comfortable as possible to fish with. This is a rare reel where beginners can get to grips with it quickly, and pros love it, too. 

This is a mid-priced reel at around $90, and it does need some regular maintenance to keep it performing, but it will last a lifetime with some basic regular maintenance care


  • Super versatile for fresh and saltwater use 
  • A delight to cast with 
  • You can throw light and heavy baits with ease 
  • A great braking system that is easy to use 
  • Pros love it, and beginners will too 
  • Ergonomically designed for comfort 
  • Excellent gear ratio and retrieve rate
  • Super smooth performance


  • Requires maintaining regularly
  • Very expensive 


  • Mono capacity LB/YD: 16/185, 20/150
  • Braid capacity LB/YD: 30/190, 40/145
  • Drag: 13.2 lbs 
  • Gear Ratio: 6.3:1/7.3:1
  • Ball bearings: 7+1
  • Weight: 8.1 oz
  • Retrieve rate per crank: 28.2 inches 
  • Retrieve Side: Right or left 

Frequently Asked Questions

What Handle Position Do I Need?

Fixed spool reels are made to interchange the position of the reel handle so left and right-handed anglers can use them. However, in most cases, baitcasting reels are fixed and cannot be changed.

Therefore, its crucial that you fully understand what option you are ordering, otherwise you may end up having some unwanted frustration!

What Is Backlash On A Baitcasting Reel?

Baitcasting reel birds nest tangle
A major tangle (known as a “birds nest”) can be frustrating and a challenge when using baitcasting reels for the first time

Backlashes happen when the spool on your reel continues to spin, but your bait or lure has reached the water. This can often lead to a line tangled around the reel, which can be incredibly frustrating and time-consuming to resolve. Usually, this requires cutting the line and spooling the reel with a new line.

Winding Up 

Thanks for reading my article. I hope you found it useful and can now choose the right baitcaster reel for your style of fishing. Baitcaster reels are very personal; you have to get used to them and build a connection, so choosing the right one is important. 

Pairing up a reel with your chosen baitcasting rod can be a big factor in making fishing successful. So, always pick a reel that matches what you fish for, where you fish and your budget. 

Why not check out all my articles on reels covering the best fly, saltwater, and freshwater fishing options.

Jamie Melvin