Beginners Guide To Fishing With Boilies For Carp

Disclosure: Some posts contain affiliate links, which earn us a commission if you make a purchase through them. Positive Fishing © participates in various affiliate networks including the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program.

Boilies are one of the most popular and commonly used carp baits one can find. But, when you walk into a tackle shop and see the selection of boilies on offer, life can get very confusing.

There are lots of different types of boilies that come in different colours with different flavours, shapes, sizes and more. So how do you know which type of boilie is right for you? It’s not very easy. 

In this Beginners Guide To Boilies For Carp Fishing we will run through all basics you need to know about boilies so you can pick the right boilies to catch more and bigger carp. 

What Is A Boilie? 

Boilies drying out on racks after mixing and rolling

Boilies are a manufactured fishing bait made from a boiled paste. They come packed full of different ingredients, with different shapes, flavours, colours and even textures to make catching carp a little easier. 

A boilie was once just a dough ball that you would put on a hook and throw out into a lake hoping for a carp to eat. However, these days boilies have come on a bit and are now mass produced with a ton of different features that make each one more suitable to a specific carp fishing situation than the next. 

What Ingredients Are In Boilies? 

Boilies can be made up of a lot of different ingredients but the basics of boilies are a mixture of fishmeals, milk proteins, bird foods, semolina and soya flour, which are mixed with egg white as a binding agent and formed into a paste. 

Other Ingredients you might find in boilies depending on the flavour/type might include some of these: 

  • Blood Powder purified
  • Chili Powder
  • Maize Meal
  • Paprika powder
  • Rennet Casein 90 mesh
  • Spirulina
  • Wheat Gluten
  • Whole Egg Powder
  • WPC80 whey protein concentrate
  • LT-94 Fishmeal
  • Pre-Digested Fishmeal CPSP 90
  • Anise Oil
  • Sardine and Anchovy Meal
  • Squid Meal
  • Soya flour
  • Tiger Nut flour
  • Blue Cheese Powder
  • Milk Powder
  • Antarctic Krill Meal
  • Belachan

As you can see, with so many different ingredients, and we haven’t even covered them all, choosing the right boilie is important. 

You can read more on fishing with belachan based baits here and also check out my article on how to use anise oil as part of your fishing bait.

How Are Boillies Made? 

Once you have chosen your mixture of ingredients, then now is the time to blend them together into a paste. This paste is then moulded/rolled into shapes, usually round balls, and then boiled to make them hard. 

What Fish Can I Catch With Boilies?

Boilies were invented purely for the carp species. However, due to many boilies being used in lakes and syndicate waters they also can be used to catch catfish. The fishy based ones work best for catfish.

Other fish species such as tench or bream are mistakenly caught by carp anglers, however, these occasions are rare. Carp anglers will typically use larger boilies to prevent these other species from taking their baits.

What Size Boilies Are There? 

Boilies come in a large range of sizes running from 8 mm all the way up to 28 mm, while the size is most often chosen ranges between 14 mm to 20 mm. 

Should I Make My Own Boilies Or Buy Ready Made?

Unless you are using a few kilograms of boilies every week, I would buy the store brand ready-made versions. The time required and the equipment cost are significant to make your own unless you plan to sell them to other anglers.

There are so many types and flavours to choose from that I personally would rather spend more time fishing than preparing and making my own!

What Are The Best Boilie Brands For Carp?

There are a lot of different brands that make boilies and some are better than others but all of them will catch fish. But, as anglers, we each have our favourites based on experiences over the years.

Here are some boilie brands that are trusted and everyone likes to use: 

  • Dynamite Baits
  • Spotted Fin
  • Shimano Isolate Baits
  • CCMoore
  • Rod Hutchinson
  • Sticky Baits
  • Nash Bait
  • Bait-Tech

My personal favourites are the Sticky Baits Manilla Shelf Life Boilies and the Nash Scopex Squid Stabilised.

Both of these can be used throughout the year and complement each other since Nash squid is a fishy type boilie and the Sticky baits is a blended milk peanut protein, bird foods and a sweeter vanilla extract. This gives me a great option when one is not working on a particular day.

How To Choose The Right Size Boilie?

When picking your boilie size there are quite a few things you need to consider including: 

  • The size of the carp you want to catch 
  • The hook size you are using 
  • How easy the boilie is for the carp to see 
  • What boilie size do you use for pre-baiting or spodding?

Fish Size vs Boilie Size 

When targeting carp under 10 lbs, use a 10 mm boilie or less. For any carp around 10-20 lbs go for 14-16 mm, and for carp over 20 lbs use a 20 mm boilie or larger. 


When fishing on big lakes, using bigger boilies makes it much easier for the carp to see them as they don’t have very good eyesight. 

Hook Size vs Boilie Size

You don’t want your boilie to be too small compared to the hook or you won’t get a good hook set. But if your hook is too big and boilie too small, the carp will work it out and spit the bait quickly. 

Pre-Bait Boilie Size 

When pre-baiting with boilies it’s generally thought that you should pre-bait with the same size boilie that you are fishing with so the carp are comfortable eating the boilie with a hook in it. 

Other carp fishermen fire out 3 sizes of boilies, one of which is the size of the boilie on the hook, so the carp happily feed on all sizes of boilies and eat yours too. 

What Boilie Flavours Should You Choose For Carp Fishing? 

Boilies come in a huge range of flavours and therefore you will have to pick a flavour when you’re in the tackle shop. 

The flavour of a boilie entices a carp through scent and if it tastes good to carp, they will hold the bait for longer in their mouth so you have a better chance of hooking the fish. 

Now, there are far too many flavours of boilies to run through here so I am going to categorize them into Fruit Flavors, Natural Flavors, and Fishy Flavors. 

Fruit Flavors 

Fruit flavours include things like strawberry, banana, pineapple, and more similar flavours. These boilies have a sweet pungent flavour that attracts carp and are the most popular ones around. 

Natural Flavors 

The naturally flavoured boilies are more citrus, almond, and corn flavoured which makes them less punchy when it comes to the scent but less suspect too. Carp are clever and a weird scent can put them off as much as attract them. 

Fishy Flavors 

The fishy flavour boilies such as mussel, squid, and fish meal smell quite awful and aren’t pleasant to carry around with your tackle. But, the smell does attract fish and can be very effective. 

How To Choose The Right Flavour? 

Choosing the right flavour boilies is all about experimentation across the flavours and the lakes you are fishing on. I would suggest picking one of each of the categories and starting there. 

Remember, what works for some anglers may not work for you. Secondly, each water you fish on may favour one type over another…………..and lastly, even if it worked last time you went fishing, it may not work the next time. 

This is why it is called fishing, and not catching!

What Colour Boilies Should You Use And Does It Matter? 

Pink fluoro boilies work well in coloured and murky water

So you have chosen the flavour and the size of your boilies and now you have to pick a colour and yes, it does matter. 

Carp can see red, green, blue and ultraviolet light and therefore see a broader spectrum of colours than we humans do. They are also curious creatures so you want your boilies to attract them but not put them off at the same time.  

All carp fishermen have their preferred colours and what works depends on where you are fishing. Crystal clear waters make things easier to see so a natural colour boilie like white or brown might be better than fluoro pink. 

That being said, fluoro pink might be the colour you need when fishing in a muddy lake that looks more like a milky cup of tea than anything. 

Light is another factor to consider, as on dark days carp will find it harder to see than on bright sunny days, and therefore using a bright coloured boilie on a dark day is a good idea. 

You should also match the colour of your pre-bait to the colour of your boilies so the carp don’t get suspicious when they see a new colour compared to what they have been feeding on. 

One final consideration is matching the colour of your boilies to the colour of the natural food the carp eat. For example, if they are gorging on worms then maybe a red or dull pink boilie is best. 

Overall it’s wise to have a range of colours from natural to high-vis boilies so that you can chop and change based on the conditions and experiment with what works best. 

How To Pick The Right Shape Boilie For Carp Fishing

Probably the most important consideration when choosing boilies is picking the right shape and luckily you only have two to choose from: dumbbells and balls. 

Most boilies come as balls but luckily they also come as dumbbells as carp being caught on round boilies regularly will end up refusing to eat them. This is when throwing out a different shaped boilie, like a dumbbell can be very effective. 

You can also shape boilies yourself using a knife and add more than one boilie to your rig so you can fool carp wary of certain shaped boilies too. If you add a small boilie on top of a larger boilie this rig is known as a “snowman”.

Which Boilies Should I Use, Fresh Or Frozen Boilies?

There are debates on this question for many years and the truth is that there are not many differences between the two as far as the fish are concerned.

Fresh boilies are sometimes referred to as shelf-life boilies and frozen ones often called freezer boilies. So what is the difference between a freezer boilie and a shelf life boilie? Well if truth be told, there isn’t actually a great deal of difference. 

What Are Shelf Life Fresh Boilies?

Live System shelf life bait is produced by using a little less egg in the mixture, to make the shelf-life boilie last longer, a food-grade preservative is added instead.

Shelf life boilies will last several months if kept in an airtight bag or jar.

What Are Frozen Boilies

Frozen boilies must be stored in the freezer to ensure they do not go “off”. The lack of preservatives in the active ingredients during the reaction process means after every fishing session the freezer bait, needs to return to the freezer.

The boilies will turn within 3 or 4 days if not kept in the freezer.

What Are Pop Up Boilies? 

Just to add some more confusion to choosing boilies you can also buy Pop Up Boilies and these are simply boilies that float. 

The advantage of using Pop Up Boilies is that they float off the bottom and are therefore the first boilie a new carp feeding in the area is going to see. This also allows you to fish in weedy areas of places with snags as it keeps the boilies out of the bottom and much easier for a carp to see and eat. 

When a carp decides to hoover in your Pop Up Boilie, the boilies floatation will also increase your chance of a hook-up as the buoyancy will help the hook go into its mouth. 

You can find pop up boilies in all the same shapes, sizes, colours, and flavours as regular boilies, so follow the advice above to pick the right ones. 

Boiling Out 

Thanks very much for reading my article. I hope you found it useful and now understand the world of boilies. It’s all about finding out what boilies work best for you and where you fish. 

You can read more about all types of fishing baits here!